Keeping it up – the Good v. the Bad

NY Times headline

Retaliating for a deadly weekend attack by Hamas terrorists, Israel is pummeling Gaza.

https://www.nytimes.com/live/2023/10/12/world/israel-gaza-war-hamas?campaign_id=60&emc=edit_na_20231012&instance_id=0&nl=breaking-news&ref=cta&regi_id=187480433&segment_id=147219&user_id=cfa6b4e4b86fdbdb8c19a263ec2bb430

So, they make sure to construct the sentence: <justification for mass slaughter>, comma, <pummeling>. You see, without the justification, it would just be pummeling, which is the everyday thing with Israel. They pummel. It’s a long-standing agreement, justified by some ancient wrong, or, property claim.

But now, they have a big giveaway! Hamas did a really gothic horrowshow on Israelis, tourist, mothers, babies, young girls. Secret (not): Hamas did this to provoke the worst Israel had to offer. The played the trump card, to decide this eternal conflict, once and for all, now.

This is a painful reckoning for the world to watch. The results will only be ugly. The results will only be ugly (repeated). These leaders are just going to kill, kill, kill, with a vehemence not really seen in other wars. There is a profound psychological dysfunction involved here, at the State level, or, perhaps cultural, or religious level. The dysfunction is that, like in a marital fight, no one is really conscious of the origin, nor of the reason, for SUCH UNMITIGATED RAGE. May G*d forgive you peoples – you Israelis and you “Palestinians”. (recall: “Palestine” has only ever been a geographic region, controlled at various times by Jews, Muslims, and Christians: everyone is a Palestinian)

Now, the attack by Hamas, in all its gratuitous violence, might actually not represent rage; rather, it is classic terrorism. Stop and review why terrorism exists: there is always an overlord world power, which cannot be overcome militarily, with any degree of might, and the underling, non-power. The underlings cannot hope to achieve a military victory, so, the resort to other techniques, like terrorism and guerilla war. These latter are purely psychological – intentionally psychological. If they are not psychologically effective, by one hair, the overlord will simply use its giant boot to stamp the underlings out. The broader jihad has staged a few of these psychological battles, notably, September 11, when a small band of rebels destroyed the emotional security of the world’s greatest power. Now, on a smaller scale, they have done the same to the Israelis – but not the people of Gaza….

Because the people of Gaza are not all the same:

Most people in the Gaza Strip are descendants of refugees who fled or were expelled from the area that became Israel after the 1948 Arab-Israeli War. Around 600,000 Gazans live in Gaza’s 8 refugee camps. Most Gazans are Sunni Muslims, and there is a Palestinian Christian minority.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaza_Strip

That’s just the Gaza strip. The West Bank:

Demographics of the West Bank

Population pyramid Gaza Strip 2016
Population pyramid West Bank 2016

The following demographic statistics are from The World Factbook, unless otherwise indicated.

Population

Total 2,939,418 (July 2018 est.); 71.72% of the population is Arab (predominantly Sunni), 28.28% is Jewish[8] (cf. Israel: Jewish 74%, Arab 21%, other 5%; and Gaza: Arab 99%)[31]

  • Palestinian Arab 2,155,743 (July 2017 est.), 71.72%[8]
  • Israeli Jew 850,481 (2016, 2020 est.), 28.28%[8]
    • approximately 475,481 Israeli Jews thereof live in the West Bank (2020)[32]
    • approximately 375,000 Israeli Jews thereof live in East Jerusalem (2016)[33]

Age structure

0–14 years: 36.1% (male 518,376/female 491,676)

15–24 years: 21.8% (male 302,474/female 289,852)

25–54 years: 34.5% (male 489,559/female 475,402)

55–64 years: 4.7% (male 68,317/female 64,233)

65 years and over: 3.5% (male 44,662/female 53,943) (2018 est.)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_State_of_Palestine

So there are some Jews who will be affected by this war – almost one million. And, as the demographics show, most are young people (the fertility rate is surprisingly(?) high in this constant war zone, although it has gone from 41% down to 29% in recent years).

The point: everyone is an Arab. That’s historical, supported by the Torah and Q’ran. This is the hallmark of an emotionally dysfunctional dispute: you only hurt those you love. Filial love turns to the most infernal hate.

This is then, not a war between nations – it’s a civil war. It’s a tribal war.

Leave a comment